Burden Of Proof In Criminal And Common Law - Free Essay Example

Sample details Pages: 5 Words: 1399 Downloads: 9 Date added: 2017/06/26 Category Law Essay Type Narrative essay Tags: Criminal Law Essay Did you like this example? He who asserts must prove. This statement of law allows us to understand that in criminal cases the onus of proof rests with the prosecution and that the standard of proof is one that must be satisfied beyond a reasonable doubt  [1]  . However, there are exceptions to this in the form of both statutory exceptions and within case law  [2]  . The statement also allows us to see that in civil cases the onus of proof rests with the party who raises the issue and the standard of proof is lessened to on the balance of probabilities  [3]  . There are two types of burdens of proof: the first is the persuasive burden which is when a party satisfies the court to the appropriate standard  [4]  . It is possible for both parties to bear the persuasive burden depending on the case in hand  [5]  . The second is the evidential burden which is when a party has to bring enough evidence in order for the court to at least consider the issue in hand  [6]  . These burdens are matter of law and will apply in each issue which is raised within the court  [7]  . In criminal cases the basic rule is that the burden of proof rests with the prosecution in order to win their case  [8]  . In the case of Slater v HMA  [9]  it was stated that: The jury was told that what is familiarly known as the presumption of innocence in criminal cases applied to the appellant (in light of his ambiguous character) with less effect than it would have applied to a man whose character was not open to suspicion. This amounted, in our opinion, to a clear misdirection in law. The presumption of innocence applies to every person with a criminal offence in precisely the same way, and it can be overcome only by evidence relevant to prove the crime with the commission of which he is charged. The evidential burden is important when it comes to criminal matters due to the presumption of innocence. It used to be the case that it was thought that the acc used was required to prove special defences however the case of Lambie v HMA  [10]  stated that this is not the case and stated that it is for the prosecution to disprove the defence beyond a reasonable doubt  [11]  . The only thing which the accused has to do is meet the minimal requirements of pointing at some evidence which allows the defence to be raised the evidential burden  [12]  . The accused must also give notice when wishing to use a special defence. There are exceptions to the general rule that it is for the prosecution to bear the burden of proof in criminal cases. There are four exceptions in which the burden of proof will shift  [13]  . The first is when the accused pleads a special defence of either insanity or diminished responsibility (which is not technically a special defence as it does not result in the accused being acquitted)  [14]  . They are named special defences as they require the accused to give written notice to the court that the se defences will be used in order for the prosecution to understand the line of evidence the defence will take  [15]  . Hume stated that when an accused wishes to plead insanity the persuasive burden will for that reason rest on the accused  [16]  . However, the evidential burden would also switch to the accused  [17]  . This is due to the fact that it would be very difficult for the prosecution to disprove this defence as the prosecution cannot force the accused to have psychiatric examinations to be done; therefore the burden is placed with the accused  [18]  . The second exception to the general rule is when other special defences are used these include alibi, self-defence or incrimination  [19]  . There is no requirement for the accused to corroborate the evidence put forward  [20]  . As well as common law exceptions to the general rule that the burden of proof lies with the prosecution in criminal case there are also statutory exceptions. These inclu de Parliament switching the burden of proof through Acts of parliament in relation to defences plead by the accused to specific crimes  [21]  . An example of this can be seen in the Criminal Law (Consolidation) (Scotland) Act 1995  [22]  which states that Any person who without lawful authority or reasonable excuse, the proof whereof shall lie on him, has with him in any public place any offensive weapon shall be guilty of an offence. However, as it is unusual for a statute to make express provision as to where the burden of proof lies the Criminal Procedure (Scotland) Act 1995  [23]  states that Where, in relation to an offence create by or under an enactment any exception, exemption, proviso, excuse or qualification, is expressed to have effect whether by the same or any other enactment, the exception, exemption, proviso, excuse or qualification need not be specified or negative in the indictment or complaint, and the prosecution is not required to prove it, but the ac cused may do so. In civil cases, the burden of proof is said to lie with he who asserts a right given to him by the law must prove the facts necessary to establish it  [24]  which allows us to understand that the burden of proof will normally rest with the pursuer  [25]  . However, the burden of proof may switch between the parties when it comes to dealing with different issues, this will usually happen when the defender is pleading certain defences (for example contributory negligence)  [26]  . The reason for this is that the parties in a civil matter are not normally required to prove a negative therefore the burden of proof will rest with the defender to prove rather than the pursuer to disprove  [27]  . There are also statutory exceptions to the general rule that in civil cases the burden of proof will rest with the pursuer  [28]  . The leading case for statutory exceptions is Nimmo v Alexander Cowan Sons Ltd  [29]  . The statute under consideratio n in this case was the Factories Act 1962  [30]  and concerned safe working practices. It was held that the burden of proof rested with the purser in order to prove that the working conditions were not safe however, the pursuer was not required to prove that it was not reasonably practicable to make them safe and if the defender wished to rely on this then the burden of proof would switch  [31]  . The standard of proof in any case depicts both the amount and the quality of evidence which has to be lead in order for the burden of proof to be released  [32]  . In criminal cases this standard is said to be one of beyond reasonable doubt  [33]  therefore, the prosecution must prove the accuseds guilt beyond a reasonable doubt  [34]  . There has been difficulty is defining what can be classed as beyond a reasonable doubt and that there can be no quantitative amount place on it  [35]  . However, it has been described as something more than a merely speculative o r academic doubt  [36]  . When the burden of proof switches to the pursuer in criminal cases the question of what standard of proof shall be used must be asked  [37]  . The case of HMA v Mitchell  [38]  states the common law position, in relation to the defences of insanity and diminished responsibility, with Lord Justice-Clerk Thomsons charge to the jury stating that: The burden of proof is on the defence, because in our law there is a presumption that a man is sane. But you must keep clearly in mind that the burden in the case of an accused person is not so heavy a burden as the burden which is laid on the CrownÃÆ' ¢Ãƒ ¢Ã¢â‚¬Å¡Ã‚ ¬Ãƒâ€šÃ‚ ¦ the Crown has to prove its case beyond a reasonable doubtÃÆ' ¢Ãƒ ¢Ã¢â‚¬Å¡Ã‚ ¬Ãƒâ€šÃ‚ ¦ Where, however, the burden of proof is on the accused, it is enough if he brings evidence which satisfies you of the probability of what he is called upon to establishÃÆ' ¢Ãƒ ¢Ã¢â‚¬Å¡Ã‚ ¬Ãƒâ€šÃ‚ ¦ it is a question of the balance f p robabilities. Therefore, the standard of proof changes from on beyond a reasonable doubt to on the balance of probabilities  [39]  . In relation to all other common law issues, in criminal matters, the burden of proof will remain with the Crown and should there be a reasonable doubt in the mind of the trier then the accused should be acquitted as the Crown has failed in discharging the persuasive burden  [40]  . The standard of proof which is required when a statute places the burden of proof on the pursuer is also on the balance of probabilities  [41]  . Don’t waste time! Our writers will create an original "Burden Of Proof In Criminal And Common Law" essay for you Create order

Organizational Behavior - 846 Words

Organizational Behavior is the study and application of understanding about how people, individuals, and groups act in organizations. Its function is to assemble better relationships by achieving human objectives, organizational objectives, and social objectives. Organizational behavior involves management paying attention to the employees’ issues, both work related and personal to make the work environment a better place. Organizational Behavior explains why an organization is only as popular and proficient as it’s employees that execute daily activities. According to Hunt, Osborn, and Schermerhorn (2005), â€Å"Individual, interpersonal, and organizational factors determine the behavior and ultimate value of an organization’s employees† (p.†¦show more content†¦Organizational communication starts with the executive management and is filtered all the way down to the associates. Communication gives every employee an idea of what is expected from h im or her, the goals that need to be accomplished, and the possible rewards that may be obtained. Some of the different types of communication flow are formal communication, informal communication, and downward communication. A common type of communication is downward communication. Downward communication is when the top management gives orders to the middle manager, and this order is delivered to the immediate manager for execution and supervision. When organizational communication is not accomplished lives are lost and that is the most important aspect of being a leader in the Marine Corps. Organizational Effectiveness and efficiency is a direct reflection upon top management. Managers of all levels must understand the organization’s strategy to produce results and sustain an orderly structure. Occasionally managers must make time for employees to be cross-trained, to understand different systems that are encompassed within an organization. Cross training gives employees a better understanding of the whole organization; therefore, enriches employees making them better contributing partners and building efficiency as products of organizational effectiveness. Efficiency within an organization is using the least amount of resources to accomplish the desiredShow MoreRelatedOrganizational Citizenship Behavior4841 Words   |  20 PagesTable of contents: Page # 1. Literature Review 1 1.1. What are Organizational Citizenship Behaviors (OCBs) 1 1.2. OCB and its link with Organization 3 1.3. How OCB’s are exhibited by employees 4 1.4. Importance of OCB 5 1.5. Effect of OCB on employees 6 2. Introduction to Organization 6 2.1. Allied Bank Limited 7 2.2. Meezan Bank Limited 7 2.3. First Women’s Bank 7 2.4. MCB 7 3. Findings and resultsRead MoreOrganizational Behavior1284 Words   |  6 PagesBachelor of Business Administration (Hons) Course Title : Organizational Behavior Course Code : BUS 250 Year of Study : 2 Number of Credits : 3 credits Duration in Weeks : 12 weeks Contact Hours Per Week : 3 hours Pre-requisite Course(s) : BUS 120 Principles and Practice of Management Course Aims The course provides students with a conceptual and a pragmatic approach to understand the employees’ behavior in the organization. This course equips students with the knowledgeRead MoreOrganizational Behavior1387 Words   |  6 PagesOrganizational Behavior Michael J. Bonnie CJA444 June 5, 2014 Eddie Gordon Organizational Behavior Organizational behavior is the study of how employee’s behavior interacts within an agency’s work environment. It includes many subjects which include sociology, communication, psychology, and management. Its primary purpose is to review and report in the ever expanding study in criminal justice organizational behavior areas in the workforce. This discussion focuses on the forces of change andRead MoreEssay Organizational Behavior1057 Words   |  5 PagesOrganizational Behavior Organizational behavior: Organizational behavior refers to the attitudes and behavior of the individuals in the organization. Organizational behavior is a inter-disciplinary field of study that draws from many of the behavioral sciences. The goal of organizational behavior is to apply the concepts from the other behavioral sciences to pressing problems that management may be facing, as well as applying organizational behavior to the administrative theory and practicesRead MoreOrganizational Behavior And Human Behavior1217 Words   |  5 PagesOrganizational behavior studies the impact of groups, individuals, and structures have on the personal human behavior within many organizations. There is many different definitions of organizational behavior, but they are all relatively the same in all cases. â€Å"Organizational behavior studies organizations from multiple viewpoints, including behavior within the organization and in relation to other organizations (Boundless.com).† This is not just the study o n one organization, but the study withinRead MoreOrganizational Behavior : Organization Behavior2093 Words   |  9 PagesIntroduction Organization behavior is the study and application of information regarding how an individual or group of people within an organization behaves. According to John Schermerhorn author of the book Organizational Behavior Twelfth Edition, organizational behavior is the key characteristic used to maintain and enhance interaction levels amongst employees within a company (Schermerhorn, 2011). There are additional characteristics such as leadership, openness to confer in relation to issuesRead MoreOrganizational Behavior And Organizational Behaviour1644 Words   |  7 PagesThe above drawn figure shows about organisational behaviour. It highlights the bonding among human behaviour in organizational settings, the individual - organization interface, the organization, the environment surrounding the organization. In an organization each and every individual brings its own experience, managerial and effective skills. Classical Organizational theory:- Popovich (2010) said that in this theory, the concentration mainly goes in how an organization can be structured inRead MoreOrganizational behavior1577 Words   |  7 PagesOrganizational Behavior: An Analysis of Helm Fire and Rescue Company Introduction Organizational Behavior is referred to as the study of individuals and their relative behavior subject to the existing organizational environment. The concept applies in a diverse workplace setting in different ways and had diverse impacts to the organization. Organizational behavior field includes communication, sociology, psychology, and management. The concept is subject to both internal and external factors affectingRead MoreOrganizational Behavior5621 Words   |  23 PagesChapter 1 - The Field of Organizational Behavior Multiple Choice Questions 1. Pharmacia is an example of a company that: a. experienced culture clashes as a result of a merger. b. ignored technological advances to its harm. c. is a great employer in terms of human resources, but an unprofitable company. d. focused on balance sheets rather than human resources. Answer a Page 2 2. _____ is a structured social system consisting of groups and individuals working together toRead MoreOrganizational Behavior And Organisational Behavior2512 Words   |  11 PagesNowadays with the new millennium speeding towards us and competitive advantage more rapidly than ever, organisational behavior is one of the most direct relevance study for deeper understanding of management context. Indeed, it’s about how people organised and managed at work, which contains the study of leadership, motivation and organisational design to examine human behaviour in relation to various psychological, social and political conditions. The purpose of study this subject from regulatory

Roberto Baggio Essay Example For Students

Roberto Baggio Essay Roberto Baggio was born on February 18, 1967 to his mother Matilde and his father Fiorindo, in the small Italian town of Caldogno which is located north of the city of Vicenza. His brothers and sisters are Gianna, Walter, Carla, Giorgio, Anna Maria, Nadia, and Eddy. Roberto had much freedom as a child. His father often took him to a soccer field where he stayed until late evening. Robertos passion for soccer was evident. Roberto started his soccer career in his home town of Caldogno, at the age of nine. His first coach, Gian Pero Zenere, saw for the first time the greatness in Roberto. He had become a star. A scout named Antonio Mora persuaded Roberto to play for Vicenza, then a club in the serie C1 league. The fee was $500. The first season the coach of Vicenza was Cade, and he started the 15 year old Roberto in one C1 game. The next season, new Vicenza coach, Bruno Giorgi, used young Roberto in six league matches and he got one goal, the first professional goal of his career. On the 15th of February 1984 Roberto was called to make his first under 16 national game. On the ninth of January Roberto played his first national juniors game. On the third day in May of 1985 Vicenza sold Roberto to Fiorentina of the serie A. The world famous ponytail was first seen on the pitch in 1987. The following year Roberto really got noticed. With such a great year, he was called up in November 1988 for his first international match. At the end of the season Roberto married Andreina, his long time girlfriend, in their hometown of Caldogno. At the end of the season, Fiorentina sold Roberto to rivals Juventus of Turin for a then record fee of 17 million dollars. Before Roberto made his first appearance for Juve, he was called to play for the Italian national team in world cup 90 in Italy. Roberto had a great first year in Juventus where he played in 33 matches in the 1990- 91 serie. In that same year his wife gave birth to their first child, Valentina, on December 2 1990. 1992-93 was Robertos best year. He also lead Juventus to the UEFA Cup in that year. It was Robertos first major trophy. He continued his great play the next season, 1993-94, when he got his one hundredth serie A goal vs Genoa in October. Roberto was awarded the Golden Ball trophy as Europes best player, and the sports writers voted Roberto Best Player in the World. His wife Andreina gave birth to their second child Mattia, in June 1994. Then it was off to USA 94, and Roberto lead the team that was built around him, the Azzurri, right to the finals of the World Cup, with goal after important goal for Italy. On July sixth 1995 Roberto left Juventus for an even bigger club, Milan. Roberto was on his second consecutive serie A championship winning team. On July 18 1997, Roberto signed with Bologna F. C. of the serie A. With the ponytail gone and new hope after a great international goal vs Poland. in April of 97 Roberto and his fans were expecting a great 1997-98 season culminating with a World Cup victory in France 98. Unfortunately his team lost in the semi- finals against the home team, France. Roberto is still considered one of the best in the world and it is predicted he will get another chance for the world cup.

Two Kinds By Amy Tan Essays (952 words) - Two Kinds, Chinatown

Two Kinds By Amy Tan An Interpretive Essay: "Two Kinds" by Amy Tan Turning through pages of stories the words within them appear to be dimensionless and static. As one begins reading, a discovery of a spirited journey is made. In the story, "Two Kinds" written by Amy Tan a crucial component she created was the narrator. The narrative voice develops the tone, symbolism, language, and characters in the story which make the story come alive in your thoughts. Jing-Mei is the narrator who is a daughter of a Chinese immigrant. As the story advances, her journey of struggle through the relationship with her overbearing mother is unraveled. Instantly there is a closeness felt with Jing-Mei. This is because of the part she plays as a protagonist. You can understand what she is going through because she is portraying a storyteller. She is a first person narrator who helps you see out of the eyes of a young Chinese American girl. The way in which she addresses herself with the pronoun I and her mother as she show that the words and thoughts are a part of her. As Jing-Mei speaks about a time in her childhood when her mother pushed her to become a prodigy, there are recognizable immature qualities she possessed. She was highly imaginative and satisfied with the ongoing process to become perfect. The words she used were highly vibrant images. She fantasizes of being "like the Christ child lifted out of the straw manger, crying with holy indignity." Her hope is to be perfect, not for the reward of fame, but for the love of her parents. She wanted to make them happy and please them. This is something that almost all children want to do. As Jing-Mei wished more and more to be this type of super kid rebellion was inevitable. This was also a trait borne out of her childishness. While her mother wanted to create a genius, she wanted to demolish her dream. This change of heart occurred after numerous tests her mother had given her to memorize bible passages and world capitals. Each time she was wrong and faltered in remembering there were continued looks of disappointment from her mother. By this time she stopped fantasizing about being something special. She desired independence from her mother and resists the high standards her mother has set for her. Jing-Mei thought, "I won't let her change me, I promised myself." Moreover she rejects the hope of being the child prodigy. With a child's perspective we can be given the truth. Jing-Mei has an honest view of the world, so we can trust what she is feeling. Her reactions and emotions are blunt. During the showdown after the talent show fiasco she protested that she was not going to anymore piano lessons. She exchanged heated words with her mother. After knowing her mother had lost her twin daughters she said the meanest thing she could. Jing-Mei shouted, "I wish I were dead! Like them." Her words displayed every ounce of strength and anger she had. The dialogue exchanged between her and her mother are sound very realistic, so trust has been established with the reader and the narrator. Jing-Mei's mother has jumbled up English words with some Chinese words. This alternation of mostly choppy English and her cultural dialect makes her mother sound like an authentic Chinese mother. She called her daughter "ni kan" and commented that Auntie Lindo's "daughter, she is only best tricky." Jing-Mei's words are also not too simple, but not complicated either. You can sympathize with her situation and the choosing of her passionate words. She sobbed and said during an argument, "I'll never be the kind of daughter you want me to be!" This exhibited how strongly she felt about expressing herself. During most of the story the tone is set by the anger and disappointment. This is characterized by the daughter feeling that she was never acceptable to her mother. She asked, "Why don't you like me the way I am?" The only way she could handle her mother's expectations was to always succumb to defeat. By the end of the story the tone takes a different turn. In addition, the voice has matured from a girl into a woman. Jing-Mei's mother offers the piano that they had fought over as a peace offering. Jing-Mei always thought that throughout her life even after the piano fight she had failed her mother by dropping out of college and not getting straight A's. Finally, she found that her mother never